Peshawar’s Consumer Protection Court fined a famous shoe brand a total of Rs 40,000 for charging a customer Rs 20 for a branded shopping bag.
Judge Nasrullah Gandapur ruled the charge an unfair trade practice. He ordered NDURE, the footwear brand, to pay Rs 20,000 in compensation to the customer, and deposit another Rs 20,000 in fines to the government treasury. Additionally, the court directed NDURE to refund the original Rs 20 bag charge. The ruling follows the same legal reasoning the court applied against Khaadi just two months earlier.
According to the judgment, customer Sarah Sial purchased shoes from NDURE’s University Road outlet in Peshawar. At checkout, the company charged her Rs 20 for a shopping bag. However, the bag carried NDURE’s brand logo. That detail became central to the ruling. Judge Gandapur observed that the bag served as an advertising and marketing tool for the company. Therefore, charging customers for it amounted to making them pay for the brand’s own promotion.
In its reasoning, the court stated that Sial visited the outlet to buy shoes, not promotional material. Furthermore, the judge noted that customers do not act as a company’s marketing agents. As a result, they should not bear the cost of branded packaging that benefits the retailer commercially.
This is the second time Judge Gandapur has ruled against a major retail brand on this exact issue. In September, the same court fined Khaadi Rs 50,000 after complainant Shafaq Aamir challenged a Rs 30 shopping bag charge at the brand’s Peshawar outlet. That ruling established the legal precedent that retailers cannot charge for bags that simultaneously promote their brand.
Meanwhile, the pattern extends beyond Peshawar. In Punjab, the Environment Protection Agency barred businesses from charging separately for plastic shopping bags starting September 6, 2026. Violators face fines ranging from Rs 5,000 to Rs 50,000.
In Karachi, a citizen took Bata to the Consumer Protection Court after a similar Rs 30 bag charge, prompting Sindh government intervention. Across the border in India, consumer forums also ruled against Bata and Red Tape over identical carry-bag charges.


















