Federal Tax Ombudsman (FTO) Zafar Hijazi has directed the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to launch a criminal investigation and take legal action against beneficiaries of a fake invoice scheme, in which hackers used a taxpayer’s IRIS account to generate suspicious transactions worth millions of rupees.
In his ruling on the sales tax fraud case, the FTO ordered the FBR to suspend registrations, blacklist the beneficiary entities and recover tax under Section 11E of the Sales Tax Act, 1990 and Sales Tax General Order No. 12 of 2023. He also ordered a criminal investigation under Section 37A read with Section 2(37) to identify the perpetrators and other beneficiaries of the fraudulent supply chain.
The FTO found that fake returns for two consecutive tax periods were filed from the complainant’s account. They showed supplies that never took place. The hackers used VPN connections, and the recorded IP addresses pointed to Indonesia and the UAE. Technical evidence did not allow the final identification of the culprits.
A newly formed private limited company was the main beneficiary of the scheme. It obtained sales tax registration one day after registering with the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP), without effective checks on its business capacity or documents. It did not submit proof of business premises, utility bills or ownership or tenancy. Instead, it uploaded a single registration document under several requirements, and the automated system accepted it.
The same company also appeared as a beneficiary in another fake invoice case. The complainant’s bank statements and financial records showed no payment was received for the disputed supplies. Transactions attributed to the Ministry of Defence and the Sindh Health Department were absent from their procurement records. The fake transactions used up the complainant’s input tax credit from previous periods, exposing it to unwarranted tax liabilities.
The FTO also identified gaps in the registration system. The procedure under Rule 5 of the Sales Tax Rules, 2006 does not cover all types of corporate entities. Director changes were recorded in FBR Form 181 while the related SECP Form 29 was still pending, and the two bodies have no system for timely data verification.
Directives to the FBR
- Form a committee to propose amendments to Rule 5 of the Sales Tax Rules, 2006.
- Set a 30-day period for mandatory post-registration verification.
- Improve verification of director changes through Form 181.
- Scrutinise newly registered companies every quarter.
- Review companies involved in fake invoices over the past year across the country.
Directives to PRAL
Pakistan Revenue Automation Limited (PRAL) was directed to strengthen IRIS portal security with the following:
- Multi-factor authentication.
- Biometric verification.
- Supervisory approval for key profile changes.
- Automated IP monitoring and validation to flag suspicious returns.
The FTO also called for an integrated system for information sharing and cross-verification among the FBR, PRAL and SECP.
The FTO directed the Commissioner Inland Revenue concerned to consider restoring the complainant’s input tax credit for previous periods. This is subject to confirmation from the Directorate General of Intelligence and Investigation that the complainant was not involved in the fraud.
All relevant bodies must implement the decision and submit a progress report within 60 days. The FTO said automated registration and digital facilitation must be accompanied by effective verification, cybersecurity and continuous monitoring. He acknowledged the cooperation of officials from the Chief Sales Tax (Operations), the FBR and the SECP during the investigation.

















