Pakistan Still Struggles to Stop Illegal Sale of Citizens’ Data on the Dark Web

Pakistan is facing a growing data privacy crisis as websites continue to sell citizens’ personal information without restriction. While the government formed an inquiry team earlier this month, the investigation has already been delayed.

On September 7, Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi ordered action after media outlets exposed the illegal trade of sensitive data.

Following the minister’s directive, National Cybercrime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) Director General Waqaruddin Syed created a seven-member team to investigate. The team was given 14 days to complete its report and identify the source of the leak.

However, investigators soon informed the DG that the task required more time. They requested a three-week extension to conduct a thorough review of how and when the breach occurred. NCCIA has since instructed the team to provide an interim progress report while the probe continues.

In the meantime, websites offering Pakistani citizens’ data remain active. Sources say that the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) has yet to block these platforms despite repeated calls for action.

The problem extends beyond websites. Citizens have reported that private data is also being traded through WhatsApp groups and Facebook pages, making the crackdown even more complex.

Experts warn that weak enforcement and slow investigations could worsen the crisis. Without urgent action, they argue, the unchecked sale of personal data risks damaging public trust in digital platforms and stalling Pakistan’s digital progress.