3 min read
In a new venture to educate the younger generation about online earning, popular Pakistani YouTubers Ducky Bhai (Saad ur Rehman), Rajab Butt, and Nadeem Nani Wala launched the project “Join Elite Group.”
The advertised project presents paid training sessions about TikTok live content creation alongside Shopify business and cryptocurrency market strategies. At a cost of PKR 5,000 this program pledges to supply users with methodical direction for earning money through online activities. There has been considerable backlash to this project launch with strong criticism specifically coming from the content creator Talha Reviews.
Talha Reviews Exposes “Join Elite Group” as a Scam
Talha Reviews, a well-known critic of online scams, strongly criticized the “Join Elite Group” project. Talha accused the creators of selling overpriced courses that provide no real value, arguing that the information is readily available for free online. He labelled the project as a money making scam set up to misuse their followers’ trust.
Talha has previously encountered confrontation with Nadeem Nani Wala. Talha revealed the course sales of Nadeem alongside another person named Anas Ali as fraudulent offers. Talha was arrested when Nadeem allegedly created fake police complaints against him.
According to Talha, during the recent launch of “Join Elite Group,” they even invited him to join in their project, but he declined.
Severe Retaliation Following Talha’s Expose
After Talha’s expose, the situation escalated dramatically. According to Talha, law enforcement officials entered his home without delivering any legal warning. According to reports 40 police officers entered his house, threatened his family members, broke CCTV cameras at his office and detained his team members.
Reports emerged that police officers kidnapped and tortured Talha’s father while supposedly working for founders of the “Join Elite Group.” This severe action has sparked deep concerns regarding power abuse as well as how far certain people will go to mute their critics.
Sham Idrees Joins the Criticism
After seven years of rivalry sparked by Ducky Bhai’s criticism, Sham Idrees has finally broken his silence and publicly condemned him. In a detailed video, Sham accused Ducky of engaging in unethical practices, including targeting the families of those who opposed him.
Sham asserted that Ducky demonstrated a record of lodging fraudulent FIRs alongside employing deceptive methods to quiet opposition. Sham listed alleged victims of Ducky’s harassment including content creators such as Froggy (Saher who is Sham’s wife) and Badla Brothers. Sham also accused that Ducky uploads scripted vlogs and fake pranks to deceive his audience.
The ongoing scandal surrounding “Join Elite Group” has ignited a broader conversation about the ethical implications of the financial models used by digital educational platforms. While some critics argue that these projects manipulate their viewers, supporters contend that they offer learners well-defined educational frameworks.
